Brooklyn Heights

Brooklyn Heights New York Eatery brings authentic New York-style pizza to Sandwich — and it's the real thing. Co-owners Silviya Peevska and Carlos Rosario trained under Union Street Pizza in Brooklyn before opening on Cotuit Road in 2024, and that mentorship shows in every pie. Signature pizzas include the Brooklyn Heights (red sauce, fresh mozzarella, portobello, artichoke hearts, ham, capicola, kalamata olives, basil), the Always Sunny white pie with shaved steak and bacon, and the Avocado Pie. Smash burgers, subs, gyros, strombolis, salads, gluten-free options, and fresh desserts from Mia's Brooklyn Bakery in Boston round out a menu that punches well above its strip-mall address. Rated 4.5 on Yelp and 4.7 on DoorDash across 100+ ratings.